Fine Spirits Auction is a public, limited liability company governed by French law with its headquarters located at 190, rue d’Estienne d’Orves 92700 Colombes, France. It is registered with the trade and companies register of Nanterre under the number B431661628, and is represented by Monsieur Thierry BENITAH, its president.
The operator of auction sales, here SARL International Wine Auction (IWA), is located at 190 rue d’Estienne d’Orves, 92700 Colombes, France and it registered with the trade and companies register of Nanterre under the number 754 038 586 and is an operator of auction sales, licensed under the number 2012- 027. It is a company that habitually organises public auctions in accordance with the relevant statutory provisions, in particular law 2011-855 from 20 July 2011, represented by Mr Cyrille JOMAND, its manager.
The seller refers to the person who wishes to sell their spirits in the context of an auction organized by finespirits.auction and who, for these purposes, stores their spirits at Fine Spirits Auction’s warehouses or entrusts a carrier to do so.
In the context of an online auction, Fine Spirits Auction provides the licensed operator of auction sales with an online platform built for finespirits.auction, allowing it to perform public auctions by proxy. As such, Fine Spirits Auction acts as a technical provider for the operator of auction sales organising the auction. The statutory provisions L.321-1 to L.321-17 of the French code of commerce regarding sales at public auction apply to auctions held on the finespirits.auction site.
Sellers accept the general terms and conditions listed below:
1 - Contractual relationships between the seller, Fine Spirits Auction, and the operator of auction sales
The signatory seller of the present deposit certificate grants Fine Spirits Auction the right to store and assess the deposited spirits for a minimum of 3 auction presentations. Fine Spirits Auction does not organise auction sales but makes its internet platform available to a licensed operator of auction sales in order to organise online auction sales. Before the beginning of the auction sale, the seller receives a selling mandate called "sale requisition" from the operator of auction sales. This mandate draws up lists of lots for sale with their description, their estimated prices, and their reserve price. The seller expressly confers on Fine Spirits Auction the right to advertise and/or photograph and reproduce, to engage any arrangement fees, handling, storage and shipping charges judged necessary and accepts that Fine Spirits Auction may be represented by any experts or specialists of its choosing.
2 - Ownership of stored property
Sellers guarantee Fine Spirits Auction and, when appropriate, the operator of auction sales, that as the uncontested owner of the property or as regular mandatory of the uncontested owner, they can validly deposit and transfer the property rights of the property offered for sale. They guarantee that the property offered for sale is in compliance with all French and European legal and regulatory provisions, especially those relating to custom regulations and tax provisions. They must guarantee that they have submitted all the information relative to the origin and authenticity of the property offered for sale to Fine Spirits Auction. When depositing spirits , a proof of identity is required and company registration certificate in the case that a professional is making the sale. The person depositing the goods must provide a written authorisation and a copy of the seller’s I.D. if the owner mandates them to do so.
3 - Estimation/reserve price
Spirits deposited for online auctioning will undergo a pre-sale assessment that will set the low and high estimates. The seller can set a reserve price which is the minimum price hat the goods can be sold at. The reserve price cannot be higher than the low estimate and by default this price is set at the low estimate. The seller can specifically ask for their property to be auctioned with no reserve price (the reserve price will be of €1); in this case no reclamation from the seller will be accepted if their property is sold at a price below the low presale estimate published.
4 - Bottle assessment
After deposit or shipment, Fine Spirits Auction’s experts appraise spirits.
If necessary, Fine Spirits Auction may call up an external expert, acting on its behalf. The descriptive elements such as the state of the labels, the measure of the fill level, the condition of the capsule, the bottling origin (merchant bottling, distillery bottling, reconditioned bottles, etc.) are determined during the evaluation. Fine Spirits Auction reserves the right to undertake all the necessary verifications to ascertain the spirit’s authenticity and, if necessary, withdraw it from the sale. Fine Spirits Auction may be obligated to remove from sale all bottles considered unsuitable for sale or consumption due to their condition (bottles with a level way below low shoulder, seepage past the cork, depigmentation, etc.). During assessment, if the level is deemed abnormally low for the vintage or the label is deteriorated, the lot’s reserve price will be lowered by 5 to 20% of its estimate.
Cork resistance is systematically tested for spirits bottled prior to the year 2000. Every bottle that has a depreciated or falling cork will be removed from sale. Fine Spirits Auction is exempted of all liability if corks do fall during the evaluation. What is more, Fine Spirits Auction reserves the right to remove plastic film from bottles if need be for the appraisal.
Fine Spirits Auction’s experts will divide the spirits into lots, unless the seller has previously formulated a specific request prior to the deposit or shipment of his spirits. After appraisal, you may ask for lots to be separated - depending on the average value per bottle - following the spirits third appearance at auction and following a price decrease.
When bottles are judged unsuitable for sale due to their state (see above), Fine Spirits Auction notifies sellers so they can collect their bottles or have them shipped - when possible - at their own expense within a period of 45 days. After this time, they agree for their bottles to be destroyed.
5 - Sales process
Auction sales are held online under the supervision of an operator of auction sales whose contact details are provided on the sales order signed by the seller. As acting technical provider, Fine Spirits Auction grants sellers’ access to its customer service.
The seller is notified that their spirits have been put for sale at auction by a sales order sent by email. This must be signed electronically and sent back as soon as possible. This order is valid for all auctions necessary for the sale of the lots concerned.
If the seller decides to remove their lots of spirits before or during the first auction, they will be liable to pay the administrative and appraisal fees. These will be calculated based on the sum of the low-price estimates of the bottles removed from sale.
Sale results
Sale results are emailed to sellers, within 48 hours of the sale’s closing date.
Unsold lots are automatically reoffered for sale, unless the seller decides otherwise. The seller can choose to lower the reserve price or request his/her unsold spirits to be returned (see related delivery charges and conditions). If the spirits are unsold after three consecutive auctions, their reserve price will automatically be reduced by 10 %. After 6 auctions, unsold lots will be reduced by 10%, applicable to the already-lowered reserve price and not the initial price. For example: if a bottle with a low estimate of 100 euros does not sell after three auctions, its reserve price will be lowered to 95 euros. If the lot is unsold after 6 auctions, the lot will then be put for sale for 85 euros.
6 - Sales commission - miscellaneous costs
The operator of auction sales’ commission fee is 12.5% (pre-tax) or 15% (inclusive of tax) of the hammer price for spirits auctions in addition to any transport costs incurred in transporting the spirits to the Fine Spirits Auction warehouses. Advertisement and catalogue fees are not charged.
Storage is free during the first 6 months following the deposit. After six months, the lots will be removed from sale. The seller can then either collect his unsold lots or offer then for sale without a reserve price. If a response from the seller is not received, storage fees of 1 Euro (inclusive of tax) per month per bottle will be charged. Unsold bottles can be collected by their owner at Fine Spirits Auction’s warehouse by appointment or if necessary, a quote for shipping the bottles can be arranged.
7 - Payment to seller
Sellers will be paid 35 days after the end of auction. Payment is made by the operator of auction sales for online auction sales, either by cheque or bank transfer if the seller has provided their bank details beforehand.
For private sellers whose fiscal residence is in France, and in accordance with article 150 UA of the CGI, the capital gain realised by a seller upon the sale of their goods will be taxed to the rate of 36.2% (19% as income tax and 17.2% as social insurance contributions) when the amount exceeds €5,000 per lot. The total of the capital gain is reduced by 5% per year since the seller has owned the good, from the second year on (article 150 VC, I-5 subparagraph of the CGI). In the case of taxable capital gain, the seller must make the declaration within one month of the sale (article 150 VG, I-4° of CGI). Private individuals who are selling bottles and reside outside France are responsible for obtaining information about and complying with the local laws on capital gains tax.
8 - Insurance
Fine Spirits Auction is insured against the risks associated with shipping, handling, and conserving spirits , on the basis of the spirits’s estimated value. Therefore, if a bottle is broken by Fine Spirits Auction during its transportation or its storage, the seller will be reimbursed within 30 days, on the basis of the median estimate given to the seller reduced by sales expenses.
9 - Force majeure
Fine Spirits Auction renounces all responsibility for any failure to meet its contractual obligations in the case of unforeseeable circumstances or force majeure, including, but not limited to, disaster, fire, internal or external strike, internal or external power outages, and generally speaking any event that would impede the execution of services.
10 - Applicable law- Allocation of jurisdiction
All contracts between a seller, Fine Spirits Auction and the auction sales operator, qualified to operate public auctions in which the seller’s spirits are sold, in these general terms and conditions, will be governed by and construed in accordance with French law.
If no alternative solutions can be found, the parties agree to submit any dispute or litigation which may arise over the validity, the interpretation or of the application of the present contract to the Court of Nanterre in compliance with article L. 321-37 of the French Code of Consumption.
In accordance with the law, all actions of civil responsibility undertaken during auction sales at public auction shall expire after five years of the hammer date.